Print-friendly Version

Return to the full version

Album Review: Katie Melua "Pictures" (Dramatico)

Still a mystery in the US, 24-year-old singer-songwriter-guitarist Katie Melua continues to polish the melodies that surround her modest romantic observations, creating an emotional arc that's stronger on "Pictures" than her two previous albums. The smoothness in the arrangements, however, results in an album too gussied up, an attempt to move her out of the sandbox with the likes of big-voiced, emotionally wrecked singers such as Brandi Carlile and place her alongside pop chanteuses. It's a safe play, one that diffuses the effect of her heart-felt lyrics.

Five years ago, before Amy Winehouse, Kate Nash, Duffy or Adele pillaged the work of '70s artists in the hunt for inspiration, Katie Melua scored a No. 1 hit in the UK with the album "Call Off the Search." After two albums--and prior to turning 21--the native of Georgia in the former USSR had become Europe's biggest-selling solo female artist.

Inspired by the confessional singer-songwriters of the 1970s, Melua has moved from that era's first wave (Cat Stevens, Elton John) to a later round (Karla Bonoff, J.D. Souther) in which simple and sentimental define the lyrics as much as the melodies. She arrived when Norah Jones was the closest model--they shared the sincerity, the calmness, the photogenic looks--but in some musical universes five years can be a long time. "Pictures" captures Melua veering toward proven pop styles and away from jazzy touches and balladry. It dilutes the sensual and wistful undercurrents that have distinguished her from a fast-growing pack.

She's a wounded bird on much of "Pictures," dedicated to a recovery that can only be achieved through love, a theme that runs through much of her work. In some cases, she aims to prove her dedication to a relationship ("If the Lights Go Out"). Elsewhere, she holds onto memories and dreams (the sultry "It's All in My Head," the gently hypnotic "Spellbound," a vulnerable reading of Leonard Cohen's "In My Secret Life").

Melua started a solo tour Sunday (5/3) in Los Angeles and performed for a half-hour at a private reception in Beverly Hills. Backing herself on acoustic and electric guitars and the piano, Melua unleashes unguarded emotion in song after song. The bare-bones delivery and the quiver and depth in her voice enhanced the nuance in the new songs, making all of the tunes refreshingly vibrant.